Are you receiving Virtue Alerts in your inbox?

Click here to subscribe to Vicki's weekly update! Have a teen daughter? Sign her up for the virtuousreality.com e-newsletter while you're there.

April 28, 2008

Miley proves nobody's perfect...again and again


Heartsick. That's the only word I can think of to describe how I feel about the Vanity Fair picture scandal involving Miley Cyrus. Add to it another scandal that surfaced the web last week involving candid shots of her exposing her lacy bra. I refrained from blogging about the latter photos when they came out last week due to the fact that it was rumored to be a Miley look-alike and I was unable to confirm if they were in fact, Miley. But alas, she came clean on Sunday in a statement to People.com where she issued an apology to her fans for the provocative photos that surfaced on the web last week as well as the photos from the Vanity Fair shoot that had at the time, not yet been released.

"My goal in my music and my acting is always to make people happy. For Vanity Fair, I was so honored and thrilled to work with Annie [Leibovitz]. I took part in a photo shoot that was supposed to be 'artistic' and now, seeing the photographs and reading the story, I feel so embarrassed."

A source close to the singer tells PEOPLE that Cyrus is clothed but shown by renowned photographer Annie Leibovitz in such a way that that the teen appears to be topless.

In the photos that circulated on the Internet, Cyrus, her midriff exposed, is shown draped over the lap of her then-boyfriend, her producer's son. In another image, a hint of a green bra is evident.

Miley, Miley, Miley. Oh darlin', we were holding our breath hoping you would not succumb to the pressures to, well, behave like the average teen girl in America. Am I the only one who thinks that Disney should seriously think about retiring these stars when they turn 14? And while I am certainly disappointed in Miley's lack of discretion, I am mortified that the adults surrounding her didn't step in and call a halt to the nonsense. According to People.com, Cyrus's parents, including father Billy Ray, were at the shoot, however they left before the final photo was shot. The article states that Cyrus's grandmother and teacher were still present at that time. Photographer Annie Leibovitz defends the photos as "simple" and "beautiful," and says she's "sorry that my portrait of Miley has been misinterpreted."

Not that we should be surprised about Ms. Leibovitz' clear lack of judgment. Her Wikipedia bio states that "Her work often has strong sexual overtones." Shame on you, Ms. Leibovitz, for taking what appears to most to be a topless photo of a 15 year-old girl and calling it "artistic." I bet pedophiles won't be using the word "artistic" when they see the picture. As a mother with young daughters, you should be devoted to protecting young women from the rampant sexualization that has become all too common, not encouraging it. And shame on Vanity Fair for publishing the photos. Whatever it takes to sell more magazines, I guess. Never mind that the girl is 15 years old and the world is run amok with pedophiles who get their jollies looking at pictures like this.

And as a side note, I hope and pray that Miley's parents are paying close attention to the public outcry. Miley's tremendous popularity is (was?) directly related to her innocent and wholesome appeal, especially at a time when few stars seem to possess this quality. If her fan base perceives that this quality has expired and she is now headed down a similar path as other child stars who have gone before her (Vanessa Hudgens, Britney Spears, Lindsay Lohan, Jessica Simpson, etc...), it could very well become a self-fulfilling prophecy. If she needs reining in, now is the time when she's still under their roof and authority EVEN if it means putting the brakes on her career. For a Christian family, the focus shouldn't be about the money, level of fame, or redeeming her career--it should be about developing her Christian character and ultimately performing for an audience of One.

We shouldn't be surprised when celebrities slip up and make mistakes in the public eye. If you watch long enough and closely enough, they will all disappoint. The same would be true for each of us if we lived our lives under a microscope and the public scrutinized our every word and deed. In the meantime, what do parents tell their young daughters? For starters, we tell them that this is the very reason God cautioned us not to have any other gods before Him. Then, we tell them that Miley made some very poor choices that she has apologized to her fans for those choices. Next, we remind them that Miley is a Christian and that the Bible says that God separates our sins as far as the East is from the West. We also remind them that we too, are called to forgive. Finally, we explain that even though Miley is forgiven, she will experience consequences for her actions. Which in this case could translate into a tarnished career, especially if it's riding on the support of a young, impressionable fan base dependent on Mom and Dad opening their wallets. And Mom and Dad may very well be growing weary of having the poor role model discussion with their children. Again and again.

34 comments:

Walker said...

I know .. I know.. this is just a very poor judgement call! (I would have NEVER agreed to VF!) I hated hearing this.. & though I don't even know the girl I feel compelled to call her up and just try to give her some encouragment some scriptures... something! I just wrote a post this morning about this.
My prayer is that she WILL learn from her mistake!
But, Billy Ray... what's wrong with you man?? I can just see my husband looking at our baby girl in a photo like that...?? come on!

CrownLaidDown said...

Been praying for her all day...wondering what is really at stake for Miley. Praying that she gets wise counsel and learns a good lesson in not letting people bring up situations that could bring harm in the name of pleasing others.

Thanks for your post, Vicki. I've been watching for it today.

Blessings,
holly

wmbgmom said...

My husband and I watched Miley on Idol Gives Back a few weeks ago and hoped that she would continue to stay true. We even saw some struggles to conform in her performances that evening. How I will pray for her... I am so thankful for sweet Lindsey Kane who was a light to my nine year old a few weeks ago in VA at You and Your Girl. My dear one was so influenced by Lindsey's heart of worship that she wrote a worship song when she got home. This is the same girl who struggles with friends and normal third grade stuff as I commented on the blog about mean girls. It was evident in every way that God was Lindsey Kane's focus and not herself. Thank you for introducing her to my girl!

Anonymous said...

lindsey kane is not perfect either.. truth is NO one is perfect..
personally, i do think these are crazy ridiculous photos.. however, i don't feel like miley really is to blame. sure we take responsibility for our actions, but she is 15.. it's scary to me to think that adults with these motives have direct influence on her choices and life.. it parallels britney spears 10 years ago (who was also know for her innocence). if you recall, she basically snapped when she felt everyone was using her for some image, and that she really had no one "real" in her life.. i think miley's parents, or a guardian should have the final say on any shot taken of her in these situations (for magazine covers, etc). and if they approve, shame on them.. just like miley, her parents also had an eye opening experience.. vanity fair should get smacked for this.. it's disgusting to think of a 15 year old in a provocative photo as art.. i hope they feel more of the repercussions than miley, i also hope her entire family learns from this not for the sake for the US tweens, but for herself. there is too much pressure put on girls in these roles.. parents need to take responsibility for that, and teach their children not to idolize, and stop throwing stones in situations like these. if the amount of pressure keeps up, we'll watch miley take the same path as the others.

Davonne said...

I was afraid this would happen...

I am glad Lily's only two. She loves Hannah Montana, but doesn't own any Hannah Montana items, and doesn't miss the show when we're not watching it. I hope Miley realizes what she's doing wrong or she is going to really disappoint millions of fans, not to mention God. I noticed the same thing as wmbgmom in the way she was dancing on American Idol and it's very sad.

Melissa @ Breath of Life said...

What was even scarier to me was her statement in the VF article that "Sex & the City" is her favorite TV show, and the character development on Hannah Montana is patterned after S&TC. Just WHERE are this girl's parents?! Even the TBS "cleaned up" version of S&TC is beyond vulgar.

Personally, I thought even the pictures of Miley & Billy Ray were a little much.

Looking at the article & pics on VF's site yesterday, I could only wonder what's next for Miley, and for her younger sister, Noah.

Linda said...

Sigh! I had just gotten done talking with a friend about Miley Cyrus as a good role model! I think we as parents should look on this incident with caution to our own youngsters about making good choices. When you look at it this is a poor judgement call by both parents and Miley. Let's not forget that Miley is just 15. Her mistakes just happen to become very public. I for one will talk to my girls about her poor choice and continue to monitor the situation. What shocks and concerns me is her parent's response. Shame on you for leaving your 15 year old child with a woman who has this reputation. I will continue to pray for Miley and her family.

lisa Lehmann said...

As my guests arrived on Sunday for my daughter's 6th birthday celebration...a Hannah Montana party...the first thing out of their mouths was regarding this scandal. That hurt because I felt my judgement as a mother was also called into question.

All I can say is that we know Satan wants to get us where it counts, and he wants our children. As Christians we need to lift up Miley and her family in our prayers. We need to call on the Holy Spirit to be ignited within her, and ask for God to place a wall of protection around her. Satan so wants her to fail as a wholesome role model.

I plan on using this moment to teach my 3 little Miley fans that everyone - indeed - makes mistakes and like you said Vicki...nobody's perfect!

Anonymous said...

My daughter is a 12 yr old 7th grader. We were discussing Miley before the pictures surfaced. She is worried about Miley making choices to drink, etc. We discussed how difficult it is to be true to one's Christian morals when you are constantly surrounded by those who do not believe as you do. As a parent, I would not have approved the photo shoot. But then again, I am not sure I would encourage the acting at such a young age. Also, I think it is easy for a parent to get caught up in their childs' popularity. We all do it to some extent with their school and extracurricular activities. I am going to tell my daughter that we need to pray for Miley and her family that they seek strength from the Lord to stay true to their faith.

Natalie Witcher said...

It stinks. It stinks bad.

Elaine said...

Beware: bunch of rambling thoughts... :)


I'm curious, who says that Miley is a Christian? I'm not being snide, I just don't know how that info. got out to the public.

No matter, I think it's interesting that if some celebrity states or is known for having some level of belief, the rest of us get all excited, like somehow they have legitimized our faith. I agree that it is encouraging and yes, Miley has seemed refreshing. She seemed to stand out from the rest and that was great.

But how many people do you know, esp. in the South, who say they are a Christian and yet do not seem to live it? I'm not talking about them living a sin-free life. I just mean that the term Christian gets thrown around a lot and used as much to define the culture in which we were raised as anything these days. Same is true in the Jewish community. For my brother-in-law it's his culture not his faith that defines him as Jewish. Or like my next door neighbor who says he's a Christian because he's a white American who happened to go to a Baptist church some when he was a kid.

It's all relative.

I'm not calling the Cyrus's faith into question at all but rather our perceptions. Perception is nothing more than an IMPRESSION we get. We think if she says she is a Christian, well then, she is our it-girl.

I just think we have to be careful.

In the VF article, Miley says about "the shot":

“I think it’s really artsy,” Cyrus says. “It wasn’t in a skanky way.… And you can’t say no to Annie. She’s so cute. She gets this puppy-dog look and you’re like, O.K.”

In the same article, Miley is quoted as saying that "sex and the city" is her favorite tv show.

It saddens me and sure I would want better for Miley. But nothing surprises me. What it does for me more than anything is want to be not just a "Christian" but a disciple, a follower. That's all.

Rose said...

I feel exactly like you do, I'm a parent of a 14 year old (almost 15)and 12 year old boy and love to come to your blog, for inspiration, advice and any 'teen related' info. When I read what you said, I felt your exact sentiments. THANKS for sharing your heart and mind!!

Anonymous said...

It has been my experience that when this much money is involved, people's judgement becomes lost in the frenzied excitement of the thought of how their lives could potentially change for the better. The Cyrus family already had more money than most, but the amount that Miley could make is beyond what most people could ever dream of. The Miley that she is at home may be far from the Miley we see in the media; this may be why her parents continued to give her so much independence. With such a talented and charismatic person as Miley Cyrus, it might be easy to forget she is still a child...this is probably where her parents failed her. I hope this has been enough of a wakeup call to them that they will retake the reins and begin guiding her again. They seem like good and loving parents so with prayer and luck, they may have a chance of saving both Miley and themselves.

Mocha with Linda said...

Thanks for this post. It makes me so sad on so many levels. Sad for Miley. Sad that her life and mistakes are being played out in public for all to see. Sad that as a society we can't enjoy a show without putting the star on a pedestal as a "role model." Sad that many who professed to be her fans will now rip her to shreds in judgment (including Christians, sadly.)

If this were an anonymous girl and not a movie star, why would this not be considered borderline child porn? Why does our society allow magazines to treat our young celebrities this way, while at the same time we condemn polygamist cults for their early sexualization of their daughters?

Your enemy the devil prowls around. . . looking for someone to devour. I Peter 5:8

Melanie said...

We said "no" to Hannah a while ago and I blogged about this a few weeks back- saw it coming. My point is that elementary kids do not need a teen or even a pre-teen role model. Kids need to watch shows about kids, not teenagers.
As for the current situation, I am waiting for her parents to apologize. They should apologize to Miley first.

Anonymous said...

I was shocked mainly about the green bra photos, at least we heard an apology from Miley. I have never been a fan of Vanity Fair magazine its no different than Cosmo. We do need to talk to our girls about the the incident. We will still be faithful fans of Miley as long as this doesn't happen again. Oh, have you seen the previews for the new movie War Inc. Hilary Duff plays a seductive French girl, now thats a shocker too. The movie is rated R

Cara said...

i teared up reading this post because it brought everything home so much. as a 23 yr old who works with her youth group, i battle with how to talk to the girls about their own strength in judgement and discretion. they have wisdom, it is building, they lack the confidence to use it sometimes. i'm praying miley will learn from these bad decisions, and DEFINETLY that the adults in her life would step up and re-evaluate how to help her grow. Always lovin' your honesty, thanks again!

Hope said...

My heart is aching for Miley and her parents. It is so easy to be led astray. For all of us. I told my 11 year old what happened yesterday and asked her to pray for Miley. Was an interesting moment. I am not sure my girl realized Miley was a 'real' person until that very moment. And that she needs are prayers just as much as our family and friends. It was a great teaching moment, for both of us.

Anonymous said...

I am a mother of a Miley fan. My friend and I have just discussed what e are to do about it and I pulled up this website for the first time.
And there it was... the Miley scandal.

I have to say that my husband and I were watching the Idol performance and were sadly disappointed. We had our 12 year old leave the room and then explained to her that the performance bordered on a very sexual nature.

It is right that nobody is perfect and that we should forgive, but I have a responsiblity to God to keep my daughter from things such as this.

I will keep reading this post and website to get advice on how to handle such things.

Faith said...

We all make mistakes and have all made poor choices if we all are honest with our selves.

Cheri-Beri said...

My daughter is 10 and a huge Miley fan. I haven't said anything to her due to a family emergency over the past week. I'm so off kilter from that that I seriously don't know how I'm going to address it with her.

As for Miley's parents and various adults surrounding her - shame on them. VF and Annie Liebo-whatever? Come ON! Maybe when she's 20 or older, but 15? I think the lack of judgement by the parents in this situation is what bothers me the most.

Shelley said...

I read that Miley's "minders" were with her throughout the shoot. Honestly, I feel like those adults lost their minders when they agreed to an interview and photoshoot with Vanity Fair. I am so disappointed over the whole thing--especially for the younger fans like my 5 year old niece.

I appreciate your blog so much and knew you would have words of wisdom on this topic. Thank you!

Kecia said...

Thank you! You said exactly what I've been trying to figure out how to say. When I saw the picture, the first thought that popped into my mind was, how would a pedophile see that picture? The messy hair, little make-up, and somber expression just make it worse. Sad as it is, we parents have to look at our children through the eyes of a pedophile before we let the world see them, and change what needs to be changed for their safety. I'm glad my girls aren't on the world's stage, but recent tragedies in our little town show that evil is everywhere.
Even so Lord Jesus come quickly.

WendyDarling said...

I was just sick when I saw those photos on TV yesterday. My first thought was, "That is child pornography" So sad.

My family and I are praying for Miley and her family. I am sure that they now know what a mistake they made. I am happy that she apologized, but my prayer is that she had a "heart to heart" with God first.

My nephew really likes her, but we have never used her as a "role model" in our home, because she is human. God tells us that sooner or later everyone will disappoint us, except for Him. I do hope this is used to strengthen her relationship with the Lord. We will stick by her, and support her. I do hope she learns from this though.

Donna said...

I have yet to let my 1st grade dd watch things like Hannah Montana or High School musical and this kind of thing is part of the reason why... I'm just protecting her innocence as long as I can.

Georgia's blog said...

I am a siesta in SERIOUS need of some prayer. My 15 year old daughter tragically passed away last night. We are comforted knowing that her last breath on earth was her first with Jesus, but ooooooooh the pain! We have been surrounded by our community, our shcool system and our church (FBC Whitewright, TX). There are no words... Just some serious siesta prayers! Probably not the topic you were looking for but please help...

Vicki Courtney said...

Georgia, my heart aches for you. I am so sorry for your loss. So very sorry. I cannot begin to imagine your pain. I am so thankful for those who are there to comfort you and will definitely be praying. I'm sure all who see your comment will join me. Please stop back in and let us know how you're doing. In the meantime, know that you and your family are being lifted up.

Father, wrap your arms around this family during their time of need. Remind them of your presence in the days to come. Give them strength to face tomorrow. Amen.

Anonymous said...

I watched Miley on the CMT Awards a few weeks ago, I was very disappointed in the dress she had on when she sang with her dad. The V neck was WAY too low!!! I knew it was only a matter of time till it would be worse... She has a lot of young girls that want to model after her... MILEY PLEASE WAKE UP our little girls NEED a good Role Model!

CrownLaidDown said...

Off subject: Are you going to Siesta Fiesta in August???

I hope so, 'cause I don't want to wit 'til my girls are old enough for your conference to meet you!

And I know you can enjoy a nice
hour or so drive and be there :)

Angela @ Refresh My Soul Blog said...

Well, I am praying about the whole situation. It makes me very sad. Fortunately my kids are to young to see those photos or ever have access so I do not have to talk about it yet but I will be keeping my eyes open.

At fifteen I would have been in the same trouble if I were a celebrity. I have no right to judge her except the fact that I thought she would have discipleship and apparently she does not. I am praying for wise Christian counsel for her. If she is going to say she is a Christian then given the responsibility she has in the public eye she has to live it. She is at such an impressionable age. Our prayers are very needed for their family. It shows me where their faith really is.

Vicki Courtney said...

crownlaiddown (Holly, right?), yes, I will be at the siesta fiesta!! I am so excited and you better find me and come hug my neck!

Patty said...

Hi Vicki!
I just wanted to thank you for this post. I was saddened by the pictures and the fact that Miley is in a profession that takes advantage of young people. Also, the over abundance of Hannah Montana merchandise etc...is overwhelming. Little girls look up to her but to me what does this say? We should teach our children not to put a person on a pedestal, not to follow anyone BUT God. May we all lift up this family in prayer.
Blessings,
Patty

FENICLE said...

I agree wholeheartedly. I also wrote a post regarding my thoughts on Miley being a commodity.

http://fenicle.com/2008/04/29/miley-cyrus-is-a-hot-commodity/

Ransomed Soul said...

Vicki,

Thank you SO MUCH for this post. I have been following the career of Miley Cyrus ever since my daughter (who is now 12 years old) began watching "Hannah Montana." I was so happy to FINALLY see a character on a show who wasn't over-the-top boy crazy, constantly mean and sarcastic to supporting cast characters, who wasn’t smarter than her parents, who dressed fashionably, but decently and didn't wear enough makeup to make the Bride of Frankenstein envious. When her character did mess up, she always learned her lesson, talked things over with her dad and then made things right, etc.

I was also happy to read that Miley seemed very grounded, thanks to both parents' insight,input and involvement in Miley's life. A few years back, an interview I read about her had Miley mentioning that she was currently reading a great book by Focus on the Family's Susie Shellenberger called "Girl Talk with God." I was overjoyed and even bought the book for my daughter.

However, I have been consistently disappointed for some months now with the whole “MIley Machine”.......the whole concept of Hannah Montana was about a nerdy but cute girl that didn't seem to fit in with the "in crowd" at school, but after school, she was a cool rock star. I've watched that all change and I was pretty much appalled at the "Hannah Montana" movie (yes, I took my daughter to see it).......her outfits left much to be desired and I was horrified at how this young girl is pushed to perform. There was one scene in the movie where Miley had four people, including her mom, frantically pawing and tearing at her hair, attaching jewelry and applying makeup and clothing during a costume change, trying to get her from Hannah to Miley in 15 seconds or less. Then she’s shot like a cannon ball back out onstage. I don’t care how old you are, months of that has got to wear on you.

Another scene showed Miley not wanting to do a part in a dance number in which she has to fall back and have several dancers catch her. They had dropped her before, and she didn’t want to do it again, but everyone (adults) kept pushing and pushing her to do it.

I checked out her concert schedule last year and wondered when in the world she has down time. Time to just hang out with family and friends, doing fun and silly things that teens do, like going to the movies, football games, the prom. Time to rest, renew and refresh. Most importantly, time to spend with God, in prayer, worship and thankfulness.

I’m 51 years old and I grew up hearing the story of Judy Garland and what Hollywood did to her. I am sadly seeing a parallel here in MIley’s life. She seems to be nothing more than a cash cow for Disney, and it concerns me to think that they will use her for everything they can get out of her, then spit her out and leave her empty on the ground, stepping over her to scramble over to the next young female “star.” Having a million dollar a week salary, which is what I understand Miley brings in, would change ANYONE. All this to say, we need to be praying and praying consistently and specifically for Miley and her parents. We, as Christians, certainly aren’t perfect nor above temptation. We need Christ as our center and our first love; we need to be rooted and grounded in God’s Word, in constant contact with Him and we need the loving support, encouragement, prayer and wisdom of other godly people in our lives, just to get us through the daily struggles, storms and temptations that rise up in our lives. So do Miley and her parents, perhaps that much more. Life is filled with choices. I hope and pray that the Cyrus’ have learned a very important lesson here and in the future, will make better choices for MIley’s life, teaching her to make better choices herself. She has a lot of young girls looking up to her, watching her every move.